|
|
Restorative Justice in Ohio
|
Community service and victim impact panels, while
not effective as a sanction, may have some benefit as part of
a treatment program for hardcore offenders. Community service
is used as part of the treatment process in jurisdictions practicing
restorative or community justice. Restorative justice teaches
that justice systems should not merely focus on offenders, but
also be inclusive of community organizations and representatives,
crime victims, crime victim advocates and victim organizations
(Wilkinson 1998).
In restorative justice, crime is seen as something done against
victims and the community, not just a violation against the
state or government. Practitioners of restorative justice believe
services such as victim-offender mediation, community service
work, restitution and other restorative concepts might reach
offenders more than past punishment.
Many statewide and local correctional agencies have implemented
restorative justice principles as a method of accountability
as well as a treatment component. Although exact numbers of
agencies that have adopted a "restorative" philosophy are unknown,
the momentum is increasing. |
"Offenders often rationalize that they didn’t hurt
anyone or that someone else can easily pay for the damages.
Community justice ensures that they bear personal responsibility
to correct the damage they have done. Offenders participate
in the process by paying restitution, offering an apology,
performing community service work or participating in mediation.
Offenders may be less likely to commit another offense if
they have to face what they have done. By removing the barriers
that separate the offender from his or her victim, and by
making offenders face the human costs of their actions, crime
is personalized for the offender." Reginald Wilkinson
|
|
|
A study (Wilkinson 2000) of the effects of community service on recidivism
in the Ohio Prison System found inmates with no community service had a
recidivism rate of 36.2 percent, while inmates with 100 or more hours had
a recidivism rate of 26.1 percent.
Ohio also has piloted a program called Victim Sensitive Offender Dialogue
in which victims meet with their offenders to help achieve closure. The
Victim Sensitive Offender Dialogue operates from a similar standpoint as
victim impact panels, except the dialogue is between victims and the specific
inmate who affected their life.
|